Favorite Ice Cream Flavor

[mommy2allyandaveri]

I thought this was appropriate since we had the Baskin Robbin's thread yesterday. What's your favorite flavor?

Mine is Phish Food from Ben and Jerry's. It is chocolate ice cream with gooey marshmellow, caramel, and fudge fish. YUMMO!!!

http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w241/kimmy624/3518430246.jpg

[Sophia]

Buttered Pecan
Mint Chocolate Chip

I like the Baskin Robbins and HEB Creamy Creations versions.

[BlackMagicRose]

Mint Chocolate Chip has always been my #1

But I will never pass down a Pumpkin Pie Blizzard from Dairy Queen
or
Vanilla Icecream with caramel sauce or hot fudge (a cherry on top is always nice!)

I do not like chocolate icrecream and will pass it up if it is offered. I love chocolate but not chocolate icecream.

[heather1029]

Breyers Vanilla w/ the little vanilla bean specks. Yep, naturally delicious!

#2 would have to be the Cake Batter flavor from Coldstone, although I can no longer eat it since it has wheat ):

[MsPeachy]

I recently had the Dark Chocolate ice cream from ColdStone and thought I'd died and gone straight to heaven!! It has now been promoted to my favorite.

Runners Up include Baskin Robbins' Chocolate & Peanut Butter, ColdStone's Cake Batter and Nutella ice cream I make myself.

[andy's di]

Tiger Tail is and will always be my favourite...there's just something about orange and black licorice flavours marbled together....mmmmm

[megc1]

Chocolate & Peanut Butter I am not picky about brand but the more peanut butter it has the better!! :D

[kelseyledare]

Mint Chocolate Chip or a fresh Strawberry

[laura]

I don't like ice cream that much, but my favorite flavor is coffee. I also like oreo/cookies&cream. If I buy any by brand, though, I usually buy Breyer's Vanilla Bean b/c it is generally to go w/ a dessert I am making. But I would much rather have a cookie, brownie, piece of cake, etc.

[Katy]

I love BR's Love Potion - but that's only around as a special flavor during February. I'm also a huge fan of peppermint stick (mmm Friendly's!) - but again, it's only around during Christmas.

Since the hubby doesn't like chocolate much, I tend to go the chocolate-ish route when out. At home I compromise and go with a cherry chocolate chip sort of thing.

[MLA]

Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia. It's divine.

[junkinmytrunk]

Don't like ice cream, really, but if pressed:
Haagen Dazs vanilla with the little chocolate covered almonds in it; used to like Breyer's Light Mint Choco Chip but they reformulated it to "creamier texture" and it's foul. Oh, BTW, I **CRAVED** chocolate ice cream (plain, nothing fancy) all during pregnancy. Must've been the calcium.

Speaking of Friendly's, I *loved* their fried ravioli appetizer - :) waaay back in the day.

[BTB]

Mint chocolate chip. Preferably from Baskin Robbins, in a sugar cone. Add a twilight stroll to get it and it's pure bliss! :)

[wendalah]

Am I the only person on earth who *hates* mint chocolate chip ice cream?

I don't like mint and chocolate together. Ugh.

[twinnyme]

Am I the only person on earth who *hates* mint chocolate chip ice cream?

No, I've ALWAYS hated mint chocolate chip ice cream, too. I just don't get it.

My favorites are cookie dough and coconut.

[bookworm]

I prefer unadulterated chocolate, not too high end (Bryers/Brighams instead of Haagen Daas). Although the little place by where I went to school once had cinnamon oreo, which lives in my memory many years later.

[AmandaLeigh]

Edy's Cherry Chocolate Chunk.

[wendalah]

I'm a big poop, I guess, but I don't like cherry and chocolate mixed either. Or raspberry and chocolate. (Shudder.)

If I am having ice cream--I like cheesecake flavor with raspberries and graham cracker crumbs from Cold Stone.

[mrs_pell]

Ben and Jerry's Chubby Hubby!!! YUMMY!!

Fudge-Covered Peanut Butter-Filled Pretzels in Vanilla Malt Ice Cream Rippled with Fudge & Peanut Butter

http://www.benjerry.com/assets/images/our_products/packaging/old/7684010012.gif

[KaliLily]

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough!! Pair it with cake (like a Baskin Robin's Ice Cream Cake) and I'm in love!

[maniach]

Mint Chocolate Chip has always been my favorite.

I love chocolate and tin roof sundae, too, though.

[Adaya]

Well it all depends on the brand and/or ice cream shop. But my all-time favs are chocolate and coffee.

There's a little shop in New Haven called Ashley's and their Sweet Cream ice cream is the best ever!! Cant' wait to get some when I go up there next week.

[May27JnJ]

Butter Pecan!!

And I say it Butter Pee-con. A Pee-can goes under your bed, a pee-con is what you eat! ;)

[ca_girl]

Top is Macadamia Nut under my shave ice in Hawaii. IN my "real life" (not vacation), I get simple, plain, chocolate. I actually had a scoop after lunch today!

[kalogrias]

For me, ice cream is just the vehicle for the fudge. I rarely get ice cream alone unless it's really hot outside.

However, when I do...

Vanilla malt shakes (my #1 fave)
Coconut and mint oreo (Tied for #2 if #1 isn't available)
Regular oreo

[PinkMartini]

#1 Coldstone's Cake Batter
#2 Plain 'ole Chocolate Chip

[mmeblue]

My favorite ice cream is Coldstone's sweet cream with oreos and bananas. Mmmm. :)

[Littlelamb11]

Chocolate Peanut Butter. BR's used to be my favorite as a kid but as an adult, I find Oberweis' Chocolate PB is much better.

In the fall, I also love pumpkin ice cream.

[petdoc08]

Oberweis' plain ol' vanilla

[Regina Phalange]

Coffee!! I hate actual coffee but love the ice cream. Weird, huh?

On a really hot day though, it doens't get any better than rainbow sherbet.

[sublime311]

Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia. It's divine.
Totally my favorite, too!! Mmmm...

Cold Stone's Cake Batter is 2nd.

[nettreefrog]

For some reason, I love fruit flavors -- strawberry, peach, blueberry, etc. I like the fresh fruit chunks too... If I had an ice cream maker, I would constantly prepare some.

[udsweetpea]

Vanilla Bean and Butter Pecan

[Niobe]

1. Green Tea - I can usually only get this at Asian restaurants
2. Cinnamon - Blue Bunny makes the yummiest Cinnamon ice cream that I can never ever find :( I've only seen it at Wal-Mart and I refuse to shop there, even for ice cream. B&J's made one, but it sucked and now resides in their Flavor Graveyard
3. B&J's From Russia with Buzz - Sadly, this also now resides in their Flavor Graveyard.

Yes, I'm very difficult when it comes to ice cream. I usually end up buying coffee ice cream of some sort if I'm at the store.

I'm also now totally intrigued by the idea of pumpkin ice cream. That sounds tasty.

[Rose]

Chocolate. And then Coffee.

[Katy]

We had a small chain in Southish Jersey, Thomas Sweet (http://thomassweet.com/), that used to make some awesome Nutter Butter ice cream. Imagine Oreos and Cream and go with Nutter Butters and peanut butter ice cream and that, my friends is heaven in a bowl! When my friend came out to visit he called all the local stores to see if *any* of them had it in stock...sadly, he hasn't seen it in many, many years. So sad.

[LRL]

Eh. I'm boring. I love Dreyer's Vanilla Bean- especially the slow churned since I can eat more of it! SO GOOD!

[Foley42]

Am I the only person on earth who *hates* mint chocolate chip ice cream?
I despise it...and that's from a choco-holic too.

I can't pick just one flavor...ahhhh the choices!

[Myra]

Dreyer's/Edy's Take the Cake -- it's a "light" cake batter ice cream. Limited edition, thank God.

[rubyslippers]

I love the green mint chocolate chip.

[Heidi9771]

any flavor with oreos in it...some of my top pics include coffee/oreo, mocha/orea, mint/oreo, and good o'l cookies and cream. :)

While I really love mint/oreo, I do find the mint chocolate chip not so tasty due to the chocolate chips often tasting bland and plastic'y'.

[MsPeachy]

For some reason, I love fruit flavors -- strawberry, peach, blueberry, etc. I like the fresh fruit chunks too... If I had an ice cream maker, I would constantly prepare some. I made a cherry vanilla ice cream last year with black cherry halves - it came out really good. The only thing that took forever was pitting the cherries ;) It's fun to make your own ice cream.

[penybryn]

The question is more like, what flavor don't I like???

My all time fav is Ben and Jerry's Chunky Monkey!

http://www.benjerry.co.uk/ouricecream/tubs/chunky_monkey.gif

[Anna]

I am generally not a fan of swirls and chunks. I like plain favors such as chocolate or strawberry.

[southerner]

Dreyer's/Edy's Take the Cake -- it's a "light" cake batter ice cream.
The American Idol one? It was way to sweet for me!
any flavor with oreos in it...some of my top pics include coffee/oreo, mocha/orea, mint/oreo, and good o'l cookies and cream. :)
My newest love is Edy's Loaded Limited edition:

http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a131/wcsoutherner/2710flavorpage.jpg

I'm not a minty ice cream fan either!

[TerpsFan]

I'm a big fan of Edy's Grand Lite French Silk. It's vanilla, chocolate swirl with chocolate chunks. Yum.

I also really like the Limited Edition Turkey Hill Southern Lemon Pie Frozen Yogurt. It's lemon/vanilla yogurt with chunks of shortbread...tastes just like lemon meringue pie!

[c'est la vie]

I love the new Sara Lee Strawberry Cheesecake ice cream by Bryers

[JennW]

Anything with peanut butter in it.

Or plain old vanilla. Good, creamy vanilla.

[Kate&Joey]

Speaking of peanut butter, DH picked this up last week and it is fab-u-lous!

http://www.mayfielddairy.com/products_icecream.html

Peanut Butterific: peanut butter ice cream with fudge swirls and chocolate-covered peanuts. It's not too sweet and you get a bit of a salty taste every now and then from the peanuts. Yum! :)

[greenbunny]

Ben & Jerry's Doonesbury Sorbet, another one in the Flavor Graveyard. Their American Pie is awesome, but seasonal. And Cherry Garcia is always fantastic.

If it's Breyer's, it would have to be the raspberry swirl with chocolate chunks, or maybe the white mint chocolate chip.

I normally do not care for chocolate ice cream, but Gadzooks! is sooooo good. It's a special edition flavor (chocolate ice cream mixed with caramel, chocolate chunks and peanut-butter brownies) sponsored/thought up by Philly radio DJs, and only found in Wawas in this area.

Okay, I'm gonna head back to the Weight Watchers thread now...

[littlelove8138]

i'm a very plan girl Vanilla i like lots of other kinds but i always go for the normal vanilla. drives my mother crazy ;)

[Sadie]

These two are tied for the all-time favorite slot:
http://i115.photobucket.com/albums/n291/sadietrap/peach.jpg
and
http://i115.photobucket.com/albums/n291/sadietrap/mintchocchip.jpg

[jesseybell]

Brigham's (boston area) Chocolate or Coffee (it only come in quarts so I don't buy it often)

If I make it to Baskin Robbin's I'll get PB and Chocolate (so mad Ben and Jerry's got rid of theirs)

I really wish someone made Chocolate and Marshmellow. I used to get Rocky Road from BR, but I don't like nuts in my ice cream. Really as a rull of thumb, I don't like chunks in my ice cream. I like to lick, not chew my ice cream.

Am I the only person on earth who *hates* mint chocolate chip ice cream?

I don't like mint and chocolate together. Ugh.

Nope, I can't stand it either.

Coffee!! I hate actual coffee but love the ice cream. Weird, huh?

I don't drink coffee - part of the reason is I started eating coffee ice cream when I was 10, so by the time I was old enough that my peers were drinking coffee, I tried to make my coffee taste like the ice cream and realized that adding that much cream and sugar to it was not a healthy path to go down.

[ManteoChik]

Breyers Vanilla w/ the little vanilla bean specks. Yep, naturally delicious!

Me too! :D Its always been the only thing. In fact, I'm so picky about my ice cream that when I eat a milkshake it has to be made with vanilla ice cream and chocolate syrup (instead of chocolate ice cream).

Sometimes I'll eat cookie dough for a change but nothing beats Breyers Natural vanilla. :)

[Foley42]

DH and I went to Bruster's tonight and I had Birthday Cake. OMG it was soooo freaking good. DH ate Birthday Cake at Coldstone, but it's so much better at Bruster's. It has frosting in it...I think I have a new obsession now :D

[Sol]

Lemon sherbet. But it has to be really tart, I haven't been able to find any that isn't syrupy sweet in US, and I'm so sad. Same goes for raspberry sherbet, my other love. Even better with semisweet chocolate ice-cream next to it.

[char473]

I second Brusters Brirthday cake. It is my absolute favorite ever. Until it came into my life, i was a chocolate girl.;)

[KiewiStyles]

Purple Cow

[Adaya]

DH and I went to Bruster's tonight and I had Birthday Cake. OMG it was soooo freaking good. DH ate Birthday Cake at Coldstone, but it's so much better at Bruster's. It has frosting in it...I think I have a new obsession now :D

The next time I go to Bruster's I'm gonna try Birthday Cake. It sounds delish.

[tlew12778]

Mango

[Fenway]

I love Pumpkin ice cream. Unfortunately, it only seems to be available in the fall. Runners up are Black Raspberry and Coffee Oreo.

There is a local creamery here that makes their own waffle cones fresh, every day. So you get cold ice cream in a warm cone. Yummmmmm..... I usually get it with Coffee Oreo.

[lovelifeandlivelove]

I like most flavors but have not found one at Coldstone that I like. Strange, I know, but they all seem way too rich.
My absolute favorites are chocolate with peanut butter swirl and the BR strawberry cheesecake yogurt (or something like) that I think it was discontinued or seasonal :(

[nyclaura]

Butter Pecan or plain Vanilla Bean

[Julss05]

My current favorite is Strawberry - Julie's Organic Ice Cream (found in regular grocery store).

Other Favorites:
French Vanilla
Chocolate Mint
Chunky Monkey by Ben and Jerry's
Pineapple Coconut ice cream served with banana rolls at P.F. Changs

[AlisonCO]

coffee - but only from the good stores that make it, not the grocery store brand

peach, strawberry, cherry - homemade

mint choc chip or rocky road - BR

[apoppy]

Pistachio, but it can be difficult to find.

Otherwise, I will take just about anything with a ribbon of fudge or carmel.

[EJH]

coffee....

or starbucks mud pie. yum.

[LittleFredPunkinHead]

I forget what brand it is- it's something sold in grocery stores- but I love the limited edition Samoas ice cream (based on the Girl Scout cookie). Yum!

And, I lurrrve Chubby Hubby. :D

[honeygirl]

Vanilla. :) And it must be Haagen Dazs.

If I'm in a wild mood I like their Pineapple Coconut.

[Ferris]

Peanut Butter and Chocolate! :)

Also I have been loving Ben and Jerry's Marsha, Marsha, Marshmellow. It's chocolate ice cream , with graham crackers and a marshmellow swirl.

[ash313]

Swensen's chocolate amaretto cheesecake. I love that stuff! Sadly, there's no Swensen's nearby :-(

[stevesbabygirl]

Cake batter from Cold Stone, yum :D!

[cr8zyforaf]

vanilla - I am dull.

[jimmysgirl424]

Not a big ice cream fan but recently was introduced to Coldstone..I managed to get myself and my sister hooked on it. I love the light cake batter with graham cracker pie crust mixed in. Other than that, I'll take Ritas Italian Ices any day over ice cream! :D

[ysolde]

Mint chocolate chip

Ben and Jerry's Chocolate Brownie

[Ribbit]

My favorite is really hard to find...I love mandarin chocolate ice cream. I've actually made it myself since it's never in stores. I also love Guiness ice cream with chocolate cake...which is weird, 'cause I can't stand beer!

[BumbleB]

Mint Chocolate Chip :D mm, yum

Followed closely by

Cookies n' Cream

[Bloomwood]

1. bubble gum, preferably with a little cup to put the gumballs in as I don't like gum
2. Cherry Garcia as my "at home" flavor
3. Strawberry as the go to
4. mint chip if it's the flaky mint

[rene']

O.K., this thread is going to be the death of me. After checking this thread out every day for a week, I was craving ice cream. So, last night, I tried the Ben & Jerry's Phish Food and OMG it was awesome!

[BlackMagicRose]

I was craving ice cream to and had THE BEST icecream last night. It was kind of like a klondike bar but on a stick and had a very thick dark chocolate (70% cocoa) on the outside! I was soooooo yummy!!!

[chefker]

Ben & Jerry's Doonesbury Sorbet, another one in the Flavor Graveyard.

This was one of my FAVORITE B & J flavors. And I never felt guilty about eating the entire pint, because it was fat free. :)

I recently tried a new Haagen-dazs flavor - Sticky Toffee Pudding. (http://www.haagen-dazs.com/img_db/pro/pro_sttpdd_200.gif)


This was a contest winner in the 'invent a flavor' contest. Oh.My.God...this is simply the best. Caramelly ice cream, with chunks of a brown-sugar cake in it...seriously good stuff.

Another new B & J flavor that is heavenly, is creme brulee. Limited edition, sadly.

My all time favorites are Cherry Garcia, and Phish Food. Mmm...I'm getting hungry now.

[shopaholic]

Edy's - Rocky Road and Apple Pie (only available in the fall)

Haagen Daz - Banana Split, Strawberry Sorbet, Lemon Sorbet

[Sin Nombre]

My favorite flavor from a specific place is Maple Walnut, from a little ice cream shack called Hallmark by my DH's family beach house in Old Lyme, CT.

In general, I also love ice cream in caramel or coffee flavors. And peppermint stick!

[j*east]

New favorite:
Bruster's (http://www.brusters.com/) Scotchy Pecan.

All time faves:
Breyer's vanilla
Brigham's (http://www.brighams.com/home/default.asp) peppermint stick
Herrell's (http://www.herrells.com/design/?int=1) sweet cream with hot fudge
Ben and Jerry's New York Super Fudge Chunk, Dilbert's World Totally Nuts (retired), Wavy Gravy (retired)

[Sue]

Edy's Slow Churned Double Fudge Brownie - I could eat the whole container!

[amwilson615]

Breyer's Chocolate Rainbow--can't find it anymore
Ben & Jerry's Oatmeal Cookie Chunk
Generic green mint chocolate chip
Chocolate

[malala]

Strawberry banana rendezvous from Cold Stone Creamery.

Strawberry by Haagen Dazs.

I'm from Argentina and we have reaaaally good ice cream there, if you're ever visiting you have to have ice cream from Freddo YUM!

chefker: may I ask you where you found the sticky toffee pudding flavor? I've been looking for it on and off since I saw that TV show last year and haven't been able to find it yet. It does sound really good.

[PurpleRose]

Breyer's Chocolate Rainbow--can't find it anymore

Come down to GA--my local Super Target has a bunch of in stock!

[salysaturn]

ho hum...where to start?

I like Edy's Double Fudge Brownie

Turkey Hill's Cookies and Creme and Rocky Road.

Breyer's Vanilla and Reeses Peanut Butter

Friendly's Reeses Pieces :)

and the little individual ones from Blue Bunny :)

[angel17]

I forget what brand it is- it's something sold in grocery stores- but I love the limited edition Samoas ice cream (based on the Girl Scout cookie). Yum!

And, I lurrrve Chubby Hubby. :D

That's made by Edy's - and if anyone knows where I can find it in NYC area - PLEASE let me know. I'm a Samoa addict who's girl scout connection had the nerve to grow up and I keep hearing about this ice cream and can't find it!! :p

BTW - my fav's are butter pecan and coffee. (forgot to add if you are ever by Penn State you MUST go to the creamery - doesn't matter what flavors - there is nothing like fresh churned nittany lion ice cream!)

[artist]

Lately I've been hooked on Ben & Jerry's Half Baked, which is a mixture of cookie dough and brownies.

[artist]

Edy's Slow Churned Double Fudge Brownie - I could eat the whole container!

OMG! Your dog's face is so cute by the way! I am smiling at your avatar photo! :)

[Sue]

OMG! Your dog's face is so cute by the way! I am smiling at your avatar photo! :)

Thanks! She's our pretty pittie :D

Hmmm, Half Baked? Brownies AND Cookie Dough??? I might just have to pick that up!

[chefker]

chefker: may I ask you where you found the sticky toffee pudding flavor? I've been looking for it on and off since I saw that TV show last year and haven't been able to find it yet. It does sound really good.

I found it at Shaw's supermarket (which I think is owned by Albertson's?). Haven't been able to find it at any other store, I don't know why it's so hard to come by!

[shopaholic]

That's made by Edy's - and if anyone knows where I can find it in NYC area - PLEASE let me know. I'm a Samoa addict who's girl scout connection had the nerve to grow up and I keep hearing about this ice cream and can't find it!! :p


I believe the Girl Scout ice cream is only around when the cookies are sold (Jan-March).

[Rose]

chefker: may I ask you where you found the sticky toffee pudding flavor? I've been looking for it on and off since I saw that TV show last year and haven't been able to find it yet. It does sound really good.

I've also seen it at Raley's which is in California.

[Standrea]

Mint chocolate chip...I'm so boring!

But, i do love me some Phish Food once in a while!!

[SeptSapphire]

Blue Bell Homemade Vanilla. I'm easy. :)

But since I'm in exile away from TX, anything caramel or banana is good for me. :D

[ginastorm]

I believe the Girl Scout ice cream is only around when the cookies are sold (Jan-March).

I agree. I'm addicted to Edy's Thin Mint ice cream and have made it my mission to find all remaining gallons at my grocery stores. Last week I found 3 gallons of it & was overjoyed!

[Wen]

B & J's Neopolitan Dynamite half Cherry Garcia with half Chocolate Fudge Brownie. Oh it is so so so good. And sometimes Godiva any of the Godiva flavors are awesome too Belgian Dark Chocolate Mint, Vanilla Black Rasp-berry, Cappuccino with Chocolate Hearts, and Milk Chocolate Hazelnut Praline. Oh by the way I love ice cream.

[shopaholic]

I agree. I'm addicted to Edy's Thin Mint ice cream and have made it my mission to find all remaining gallons at my grocery stores. Last week I found 3 gallons of it & was overjoyed!

I got Samoa and the Peanut Butter patty kind back in Jan. Both were so-so. Next time I will have to get the thin mint.

[ellidew]

I don't really have a favorite flavor but I LOVE Breyers Vanilla Bean with Cinnamon and Honey drizzled on top and if i'm feeling really frisky ;) i'll put some corn flakes in a bowl and spray it with a little butter and microwave it for a 30 seconds to toast them and then crumble those over it. It's my own version of fried ice cream!

[Kristy]

Baskin Robbin's Chocolate Chip or Pralines and Cream. I worked there in h.s. and became quite the ice cream expert :)

[Anna Low]

Mayfield's Chocolate Almond
Bluebell Birthday Cake
any brand of chocolate-coconut (pretty hard to find commercially)

I love ice cream. And cake. And cookies. And Hostess Cupcakes.

[ginastorm]

I got Samoa and the Peanut Butter patty kind back in Jan. Both were so-so. Next time I will have to get the thin mint.

You won't be disappointed with the Thin Mint. I tried the Samoa and just thought it was alright too.

[amwilson615]

Come down to GA--my local Super Target has a bunch of in stock!

Man! It is nowhere here in WV. They have a new flavor that I tried out yesterday--Triple Chocolate. It's like the rainbow but missing two options. :p

[Rose]

I love ice cream. And cake. And cookies. And Hostess Cupcakes.

You lost me at Hostess Cupcakes but now I really want some cake and ice cream. Yum!

[Rosebud]

I'm not loyal to any particular brand, but Pecan Praline is generally my favorite flavor.

[DisneyGirl]

mint Chocolate Chip

[angel17]

I believe the Girl Scout ice cream is only around when the cookies are sold (Jan-March). Maybe they only sell certain flavors in certain areas - I've seen the Thin Mint and Peanut Butter Patty one just never the Samoa's here.

[JLRenheos]

I love GRAETER'S Mint choc. chip.

[manda_kate]

I love Breyer's Peach, Edy's Nestle Toll House Cookie Dough, and Haagen Dazs Light Blueberry Cheesecake. I love ice cream!

[1_mommy]

breyers rocky road, and dreyers mint chip!

[Tracie]

I love chocolate chip cookie dough, especially by Ben and Jerry's.

[QueenDillyDally]

GODIVA Chocolate Raspberry Truffle.....

http://www.coolbrandsinc.com/brands/godiva/pints/web_art/CRT_LG.jpg

It is the best thing on EARTH!!!!

*Although, now I can't find it anywhere around here. I even emailed the company and they said that there was a problem with their supplier and they don't know when/if it will be available in the future. :(

[DianeCourt]

Ben & Jerry's Oatmeal Cookie Chunk. Heaven. :)

[AHammer]

Dryer's (I think) Girl Scout Thin Mint. It's chocolate ice cream w/ crushed up thin mints.

Blue Bell chocolate chip cookie dough.

[CarolinaGirl]

Bryers Natural Peach has ALWAYS been my absolute favorite! In general I prefer the Bryers natural ice creams because they taste so much like homemade.

[May27JnJ]

Snickers before WW

[maggieb]

I am so boring. I love, love, love vanilla. My all-time favorite!

[Tonysweetie]

I am so boring. I love, love, love vanilla. My all-time favorite!

Me too!

[malala]

Thank you for the tips on finding the Sticky Toffee Pudding ice cream. I found it and it was YUM.

But I also discovered English Toffee by Haagen Dazs and that's even better!

[sue-bert]

I like:

Chocolate-chip mint (no particular brand)
Orange chocolate and chocolate hazelnut (my favorite flavors from Toscaninni's when I lived in Cambridge, MA)
Panna Cotta gelatto (no particular brand)
Pistacio gelatto (no particular brand)

[j*east]

Thank you for the tips on finding the Sticky Toffee Pudding ice cream. I found it and it was YUM.

YEAH. Me too. And there's a Food Network show called Scoop (http://www.foodnetwork.com/food/show_sp/episode/0,1976,FOOD_9994_44199,00.html)that tells about how this flavor won a contest. It's on right now, but I don't know if it will be on again.

[ellejay]

I LOVE Ben & Jerry's Everything But tha......

I'm sad to say though that it seems like it's not being sold as much around here anymore. :(

[bellezzadolce]

Cookies & Cream!

[Rosebud]

Here's a random ice cream related question... has anyone seen the Ben & Jerry's flavor "Stephen Colbert's AmeriCone Dream (http://www.benjerry.com/features/americone_dream_index.cfm)" in stores? Anyone ever tasted it? My DH is obsessed with finding it, but it's nowhere here. When we were in Vermont last month he went into every market he saw to look for it, but never found it.

:confused:

[jennylou]

Curse you, Rosebud, now I want donuts and icecream!

[lucycat]

i forget the brand but i am loving caramel pretzel ice cream yummmmmm. there is even a klondike bar in this flavor.

[mama2a&g]

Ben & Jerry's Creme Brulee. It's a new flavor, and it is the best ice cream ever.

[sublime311]

I have a new favorite - Blue Bell's Birthday Cake - it's sooooo yummy!

Blue Bell's Banana Split is quite tasty, too!

[Sumike]

Sheer Bliss - Pomogranite with Dark chocolate slivers

[laurenc]

Edy's Loaded chocolate peanut butter cup -- especially when topped with peanut butter sauce! That and Girl Scout cookie thin mint ice cream.

[BumbleB]

Mint Chocolate Chip will always be my favorite.

but I also love -

Moose Tracks (vanilla ice cream with fudge swirls, chocolate covered peanut butter pieces - yum).


I very rarely eat ice cream but it is so good - this is making me hungry! ;)

[emjay]

Ben and Jerry's Cinnamon Buns. ::drooool::