Maui Chat

[Rosebud]

Here's a new thread to discuss travel to Maui, Hawaii!

You can also reference these old threads for more information on Maui:

Hawaii Chat (http://www.constantchatter.com/forum/showthread.php?t=3924)

Maui: Where Would You Stay? (http://www.constantchatter.com/forum/showthread.php?t=29744)

[justHB]

That's a great looking condo!

Four our trip, we also decided to stay in a condo. So far, it has me wishing we'd booked a hotel. They sent me the keys on Monday, but somehow they wound up in LA. They supposedly re-sent a set that is supposed to arrive today. It's just too much stress. I like the idea of showing up to a hotel, checking in, and being done with it.

[Ohana]

I know that Lanai and Molokai aren't as often traveled, but perhaps we should include them in this Maui thread?

[justHB]

I think that's a good idea, especially since you can easily take trips to each from Maui. In fact, we have a day trip to Lanai planned to for Tuesday.

[Ohana]

JustHB Are you just going over to snorkel and dolphin watch? Or are you renting a car and going up to the town? Are you taking the ferry or Trilogy? DH is from Lanai, so I've been there many times (and will be there again this summer). The beaches are fabulous, much better than Maui (though I am likely biased).

[Rosebud]

(Holding space for future TOC)

[Sol]

Just wanted to mention that ATA had $99/leg fares to Maui (from CA) last weekend, and they still have some promos (I'm waiting for next weekend to see if they bring the $99 back). We're in WA and it was $199/leg I think.

[justHB]

JustHB Are you just going over to snorkel and dolphin watch? Or are you renting a car and going up to the town? Are you taking the ferry or Trilogy? DH is from Lanai, so I've been there many times (and will be there again this summer). The beaches are fabulous, much better than Maui (though I am likely biased).We're taking the Trilogy tour. Any good?(Holding space for future TOC)What's TOC?Just wanted to mention that ATA had $99/leg fares to Maui (from CA) last weekend, and they still have some promos (I'm waiting for next weekend to see if they bring the $99 back). We're in WA and it was $199/leg I think.This makes me so sad. We booked with ATA back in November and are paying about $400/person direct from Oakland.

[laura]

TOC=Table of Contents, IIRC

[Ohana]

JustHB If you're willing to pack your own lunch and snorkeling equipment, I would recommend taking the ferry. That is, unless you got a really killer deal on the Trilogy Tour. The ferry is $50 round trip, IIRC and has multiple sailings a day. You would catch the ferry in Lahaina (near the Trilogy boat) and it drops you off at the same harbor Trilogy would. Sure, you'd have to take your own lunch and snorkeling gear, but it's a huge savings. You would also have more flexibility schedule wise, since the ferry sails multiple times a day.

Edited to add that I've never gone on a Trilogy tour (with a local boy husband, he gives me private snorkeling tours!). I've heard they're pretty good, but expensive. I'm a cheapskate and would far prefer taking the ferry.

[Makena]

We're going on our second trip to Maui in October. We'll be staying for 10 days. We weren't planning on a return trip until next year, but I came across some great prices for flights that I couldn't pass up. In order to save even more money, we've opted not to stay at a posh resort for the whole trip. We'll be in a condo for 7 nights, and then one of the Ka'anaplai resorts for the last 3 days.

I found this great Lahaina condo on www.vrbo.com, The Outrigger Aina Nalu (http://www.outriggerainanalucondo.com). I was able to negotiate a price of $140/per night. It's located just steps from Front Street. It's not on the beach, but that not a huge deal for us. It's a 2 bedroom, 1 bath newly renovated condo. It has a full kitchen with a dishwasher! That'll help us cut down on our dining out expenses.
And check out that bathroom!!

http://www.outriggerainanalucondo.com/images/OUTAinaNalu_Exterior1.jpg
http://www.outriggerainanalucondo.com/images/OUTAinaNalu_Exterior2.jpg
http://www.outriggerainanalucondo.com/images/OUTAinaNalu_Pool1.jpg
http://www.outriggerainanalucondo.com/images/OUTAinaNalu_2Bdrm_3.jpg
http://www.outriggerainanalucondo.com/images/OUTAinaNalu_1BdrmBath.jpg
http://www.outriggerainanalucondo.com/images/OUTAinaNalu_Studio_2.jpg

[justHB]

JustHB If you're willing to pack your own lunch and snorkeling equipment, I would recommend taking the ferry. That is, unless you got a really killer deal on the Trilogy Tour. The ferry is $50 round trip, IIRC and has multiple sailings a day. You would catch the ferry in Lahaina (near the Trilogy boat) and it drops you off at the same harbor Trilogy would. Sure, you'd have to take your own lunch and snorkeling gear, but it's a huge savings. You would also have more flexibility schedule wise, since the ferry sails multiple times a day.

Edited to add that I've never gone on a Trilogy tour (with a local boy husband, he gives me private snorkeling tours!). I've heard they're pretty good, but expensive. I'm a cheapskate and would far prefer taking the ferry.Oh, it was expensive all right, but what I liked about it - that we couldn't have gotten on our own - was the fact that they take you up into Lanai and show you around. Also, I hate snorkeling from shore. For some reason, I would much rather jump off a boat in the middle of the ocean and snorkel than walk in on my own. I doubt the ferry would go for that. :p We typically set aside $$$ for each vacation to do 1-2 big things. This tour happens to fall into that category.

[Ohana]

JustHB Enjoy the tour! Please report back on how it goes, because people have asked me about it a lot (as soon as they hear DH is from Lanai). Also, just FYI, but there is a shuttle that will transport you from the ferry up to Lanai City and back. There's not much to see, so once you take the shuttle up to the Lodge at Koele or whatever it's called these days, you've seen it all. We've used it ourselves rather than renting a car when we're there.

[ca_girl]

I'm going in August & will be staying at the Wailea Marriott. We used to always stay at the Fairmont, but since it's closing, we decided to try out the Marriott.

[ejs]

I'm going in August & will be staying at the Wailea Marriott. We used to always stay at the Fairmont, but since it's closing, we decided to try out the Marriott.

The Kea Lani is closing? When? Why?

[ca_girl]

The Kea Lani is closing? When? Why?

OMG... where did I get Fairmont from? I meant the Renaissance! Holy crap. I'm losing it! Sorry!

[justHB]

*whew* you had me worried there for a minute, ca_girl!

I'm posting from the bedroom of our ocean view Kapalua condo. It is simply breathtaking. The winds are fierce (there is a storm from approaching) and we had insane rainstorms over night, but right now the weather is sunny and warm (although I can see a big, black cloud approaching).

For those who are trying to decide between the various resorts in Kaanapali, I have to say, that I wasn't all that impressed with either the Hyatt or the Westin when we walked through each last night. Maybe the rooms/service are great, but I just didn't like the common areas. The Ritz reminds me of the Fairmont Orchid on the Big Island in style and ambiance.

Aloha!

[Cricket4]

So ladies, one of the last pieces of our trip to decide on is which luau to book (I hear the good ones book up way in advance, and we're already running short on time).

So, do y'all prefer the Old Lahaina Lu'au or the Feast at Lele? Both sound great, but if there's a good reason one might be better than another, let me know!

[justHB]

Makena - We've been driving by that condo a lot during our trip and when you gook (if you haven't already), make sure you get a room facing toward the ocean (not ocean view since it's a couple of blocks from the beach), otherwise, you might end up looking out over the highway or a really shitty looking apartment complex with a lot of rusted metal in the yard. About 1.5 blocks down the area becomes cute, but right there it's kind of ugly.

[Makena]

Thanks Becky! We've already booked, but I'm not sure where our room faces. I'll have to give them a call.

[kris97]

So ladies, one of the last pieces of our trip to decide on is which luau to book (I hear the good ones book up way in advance, and we're already running short on time).

So, do y'all prefer the Old Lahaina Lu'au or the Feast at Lele? Both sound great, but if there's a good reason one might be better than another, let me know!

we followed the advice of Maui Revealed and booked the Old Lahaina luau. while we don't have a basis of comparison, we really enjoyed it - both the food and the entertainment.

[HeatherFL]

I haven't been to the Feast at Lele, but loved the Old Lahaina Luau! Definitely the most authentic luau on the island.

~H.

[JFlo]

I'm glad there is positive feedback on the Old Lahaina Luau. We just booked the show a few days ago for our trip in May.

[justHB]

The Trilogy tour to Lanai was good in that everything was done for us; all we had to do is show up and go. In reading the information on the website, I somehow fell into the impression that we'd be anchoring off the coast and snorkeling, but that was not the case. We pulled into the harbor, took a van tour of Lanai, then came back down to shore for snorkeling off the beach in front of the Manale Bay Hotel. Again, not really what I had envisioned, and given the price, I was somewhat disappointed. That said, the weather was fantastic and the snorkeling was great, so it was a good time. But yeah, kind of expensive for what you get.

Now that we're back, if I had to do it all over again, I don't think I would stay in Kapalua. It's not that I didn't like Kapalua, because I did, but the weather was AWFUL. We had gale force winds (30+ mph) every night and torrential rainstorms that were so loud they'd wake me up. Fifteen minutes away in Lahaina the weather was gorgeous. I hear this is something that only happens in the winter, so maybe if I was going in the summer, I'd stay there, but NOT in the winter. That said, our favorite beaches during the trip were Kapalua Bay and Napili Bay and they're right there, so there's that.

[wendalah]

I was pretty disappointed in Lanai in general when we visited. It was boring and didn't feel like Hawaii to me at all. The snorkeling there was amazing, though!

[Ohana]

Thanks for reporting back on the Trilogy tour, JustHB! I'll keep telling people to skip Trilogy and take the ferry over. Way cheaper and more flexible WRT time. They can always take the shuttle up to Koele if they want to see the village.

[justHB]

FYI - photos from our trip over in the travel photo thread.

http://www.constantchatter.com/forum/showthread.php?t=5422 (start at post 422)

[Makena]

HB, those pictures are fabulous!

[ladyco4]

We just got back from our week long stay on Maui. We stayed at the Mahana at Kaanapali. They are condos but are run/maintained by ResortQuest.
My DH, DD, SIL and I had reservations for 2 studios. When we checked in we were given our keys and we went to check out our rooms. DH and I got a 1 bedroom 2 bath suite! The kitchen was a bit dated(think '80's cabinetry/appliances) but very clean. There was carpeting throughout the condo and in places it was a little dirty. But we didn't care. The living room/dining room was huge and had a large picture window looking out onto the ocean. The bedroom was also huge with a large picture window looking out onto the ocean. The furniture wasn't to my taste but it was clean and comfy.
DD came over and told us that they had turned down the first room that they were given because the carpet was dirty. She was going to check out the other room. We checked out the other room and it had new tile throughout the studio but had dated kitchen cabinets. DD/SIL decided to take the second room. If they hadn't liked that room they could have looked at as many rooms as they needed to find one they liked! We asked the desk clerk why DH/I had a 1 br/2ba suite instead of the studio?(not that we were complaining!) We were told that the owner had it classified as a studio because it didn't have a sleeper sofa.( to be able to qualify as a 1 bedroom. the condo has to be able to sleep 4 people). So DH and I lucked out!

Every morning we sat on our lanai and had breakfast and watched the whales. What a sight they were. Some mornings they were only about 100 yards away! I would have been very happy whale watching all day. The first day that we were there we watched one jump up in the air over and over again. We must have watched for 30 minutes. What a way to start a vacation. We had perfect weather every day. It started to rain yesterday when we left but even the rain was nice!

The staff at the Mahana were very friendly and accomadating. There isn't a restaurant at the condo but there are 2 restaurants within walking distance that you can eat at and charge your meals to your room.
All of their rooms are ocean view and they are right on the beach.

DD/SIL went snorkeling about 150 feet away from the condos and it was amazing they said.
We went on one of the Trilogy snorkeling tours to Molokini. It was a bit choppy when we were there so DH/I didn't enjoy it too much. (We're not strong swimmers.) DD/SIL had a great time. Our second dive was at Wailea to see the sea turtles. It was alot calmer there and the sea turtles were awesome.

We went to the Old Laihana Luau and had a great time. The entertainment was beautiful and the food was very good.

We didn't do the road to Hana after hearing about the narrow roads and steep drops. My DH likes to sightsee as he is driving and we didn't want to go over a cliff because he was looking at something other than the road!!

We had the best vacation ever and we will be going back to Maui again soon.

Aloha

Ruth

[justHB]

$279-$318 -- Fly to Hawaii from the Bay Area, Roundtrip
http://airfare.travelzoo.com/north-american-airfare/290752

$199 -- Stay Beachfront in Maui, 40% OFF (Sheraton Maui)
http://hotels.travelzoo.com/hawaii-hotels/290584

[laura]

you=devil!

[Makena]

We need more Maui chat!

Is anyone heading off to paradise soon?

[Ohana]

Is anyone heading off to paradise soon?
Me me me! We're headed over for our nephew's graduation in May/June and decided to extend our trip so we can take a side trip to Maui (IL's live on Lanai). It's also our 5th wedding anniversary this year, and since we got married on Maui, it seemed like the perfect time for a visit. No idea where we'll be staying yet, as SIL is making the hotel arrangements, but I can't wait!

Aside from Aloha Mix Plate, anyone have suggestions for casual, child friendly (we'll have our 3 yo and 9 mo DDs with us) restaurants that serve yummy local food?

[JFlo]

Me too! We leave in 5 weeks!

We want to make dinner reservations at Nick's Fishmarket and Mama's Fish House...do you think it's too early to make both reservations this week?

[laura]

I don't know if it's too early, I never do things in advance. :p I waited until 1-2 weeks before our trip to make our reservation for Nick's and I couldn't get anything before 9pm, which normally would have been okay but it was our first night there and we were so jet-lagged. That said, that is the only reservation I made in advance; the rest I had the hotel concierge make for us 1-2 nights in advance and it was fine. But I *think* some hotels may have more 'pull' than others w/ getting reservations.

[Ohana]

yahoo! We're headed over to Maui in just over 3 weeks! I can't wait.

Any new places we should check out? We were last there Christmas 2004, so it's been a while.

[wine_o_girlie]

Me too! We leave in 5 weeks!

We want to make dinner reservations at Nick's Fishmarket and Mama's Fish House...do you think it's too early to make both reservations this week?

Haven't been to Nick's but looooooved Mama's Fish House and I would definitely go ahead and make a reservation. Try to get a table in the "front row" closest to the beach.

[justHB]

I've eaten at both Nick's and Mama's and enjoyed aspects of both places, but thinking back, they weren't the *best* meals we had on the island.

[JFlo]

Thanks, laura, wine o girlie, and justHB! Just after I posted that message, I went ahead and made reservations at both restaurants for before sunset.

justHB - We settled on Nick's and Mama's based on recommendations from friends. It sounds like you may have some other restaurant recs under your sleeve...care to share? :)

We leave for Maui on Thursday...can't wait!!!

[Ohana]

Not JustHB, but my absolute favorite restaurant on Maui is Aloha Mix Plate. It's right next to the Old Lahaina Luau. Definitely not fancy, but the food is delicious and the prices are reasonable. Even my picky local boy likes it there.

[richgal]

I am probably the only person on the planet who dislikes Mama's Fish House. The food was good, not necessarily great, but we had HORRENDOUS service. Our appetizers took an hour to come out after we had ordered, with no apologies from the waitstaff. Main course was another hour. There weren't any big parties there or anything, so I'm not sure what the hold-up was.

We made up for that bad experience with a stellar meal at David Paul's Lahaina Grill. It's in Lahaina, about a block away from the beach (which means no views), but the food (and service!) were fabulous.

Ohana -- For local food, most of my recommendations are for the south end -- we stayed in Wailea on our most recent trip. We loved Kihei Cafe for breakfast/lunch (in Kihei). Da Kitchen (also in Kihei) is good (and cheap), too. I think Aloha Mixed Plate is better, but Da Kitchen is a nice compromise on the South side. LuLu's (in Kihei) is a good family-friendly place with decent food and a huge variety. And you MUST stop at Local Boy Shave Ice in Kihei -- the best shave ice on the island! Get it with ice cream on the bottom and topped with Kauai cream. I'm drooling just thinking about it.

[justHB]

While I loved the ambiance of Mama's and thought our service was decent (a couple that arrived after us with a reservation that was for 15 minutes after us was seated before us at a better table and that really frustrated me), the only portion of the meal that I loved was the appetizer. I thought our dinners were both okay, but *way* overpriced.

I ate at Nick's five years ago, so my memory is a bit hazy. My meal was decent, but I ordered wrong. DH's meal was fantastic. Don't get any fish wrapped in bacon, no matter how much you love bacon. The service was attentive and while at the time I was impressed at the time, a couple of days later, I remembered it being overly attentive b/c we were trying to have a nice, romantic dinner the night before our wedding, but we kept being interrupted. I remember liking the ambiance, but it's definitely not on the water or beachy.

My favorite food this time around was from Aloha Mixed Plate. Cheap, but a great location, and delicious local food.

I've heard amazing things about David Paul's Lahaina Grill, but have never been. We had reservations this last trip but cancelled. After spending nearly $200 on a meal at Mama's, we didn't want to spend a ton of money on another meal that could potentially underwhelm us since we live amongst some of the best restaurants in the country.

The Lahaina Oyster Company was okay. We had to sit inside, downstairs b/c we weren't ordering off the fancy menu. The food was good, but the atmosphere was awful. The pricier menu is for diners sitting upstairs, outdoors, overlooking Lahaina Harbor. That was a gorgeous location and had we been in the mood for fancy, we might have gone that route. Since our food was good, I imagine it would have been just as good upstairs.

I liked the breakfast buffet at the Ritz-Carlton, but didn't think it was AMAZING. I hear the one at the Four Seasons is not to be missed.

[ambula704]

I have to second the breakfasts at the Four Season. We stayed there and had it every morning. Its one of the main reasons I want to go back! All the fresh fruit and juices, not to mention the macadamia nut pancakes and coconut syrup! And the best bacon we had ever tasted!!

Have fun in Maui, we went on our honeymoon last June and I am envious of those of you about to leave for paradise!

[laura]

Mmm, breakfast at the Four Seasons! We had that every morning, also. IIRC, it was included in our package and that helped b/c it is pricey (for breakfast) but definitely worth the splurge/drive if you aren't staying at the FS.

I am another person who did not care for Mama's Fish House. I just thought it was really overrated and overpriced for what we got; our service was okay, not outstanding. My favorite meal on the island was a toss up between Spago at the Four Seasons (MUCH better than our local Spago, IMO) and another place that I can never remember the name of - sorry! It's near Wailea/Kihei, it looks kind of like a dive when you drive up, but it's right on the beach and has a phenomenal sunset view. Delicious tiger prawns, and HUGE. It's in Maui Revealed, that's how I found it, but I've loaned my copy to someone so I can't check. We also had good sushi at Sansei; we went to the one in Kihei, but I think there are 2 locations on the island (?).

[GoCougs]

My favorite meal on the island was a toss up between Spago at the Four Seasons (MUCH better than our local Spago, IMO) and another place that I can never remember the name of - sorry! It's near Wailea/Kihei, it looks kind of like a dive when you drive up, but it's right on the beach and has a phenomenal sunset view. Delicious tiger prawns, and HUGE. It's in Maui Revealed, that's how I found it, but I've loaned my copy to someone so I can't check. We also had good sushi at Sansei; we went to the one in Kihei, but I think there are 2 locations on the island (?).

Is that restaurant Sarento's?? I've only been there once, but the food was amazing and the views were something to behold. Pretty small place with an outdoor patio...awesome.

[justHB]

The other Sansei is up in Kapalua near the Ritz. If you plan on going, give yourself *plenty* of time and expect a long wait. Everytime we drove by it, there was at least 50 people waiting outside. We never went b/c of that.

[wine_o_girlie]

justHB - definitely try David Paul's next time you go to Maui for a fancy dinner. We actually went twice it was so good. We missed the view of Mama's but the food was fabulous. We sat at the bar both times (full menu served there) and loved the bar tenders and just chatting with people.

Aloha Mixed Plate - very good stuff. We enjoyed it a lot for cheap, local food. We also loved the Jaws Fish Taco truck near Makena. Loved the fish taco with guacamole. :)

Sansai in Kapalua - so good and worth the 45 minute wait. I'm not really into sushi but even to me it was good. My husband was in heaven.

Re: Mama's and service - we actually had amazing service and an amazing table but I think that was probably because we have a friend who lives on the island and he called that day and got us "hooked up". Our waitress was very, very nice and the whole evening was just wonderful.

Breakfast at the Four Seasons sounds heavenly!

[justHB]

From SFGate's Aloha Friday section:

Maui: Four Seasons Turns A New Leaf
It might be time to take a second look at Hawaii's first (and only) AAA Five Diamond and Mobil Five Star resort, the Four Seasons in Wailea. For one thing, if you stay four nights, the fifth night is free now until June 30 and Sept. 1–Dec. 18 (with the exception of Thanksgiving week); rates start at $570 per room, per night. For another, all guest rooms and suites (some of which have lanais bigger than studio apartments) have been renovated with modern Hawaiian furnishings (replacing the previous elegant but austere look) and specially commissioned artwork by local artists. Bedrooms and living areas now have large flat-screen, high-definition TVs, iPod docking stations and high-speed wireless access. The hotel doesn't tout it, but star-watching is also a plus: Arnold Schwarzenegger and Eddie Murphy have been sighted in the gym and poolside cabanas, respectively. Call (808) 874-8000 or visit (fourseasons.com/maui).

[laura]

YES, Sarrento's!! Highly recommend!

[wildcat]

I'm looking for some advice...

My DH and I are celebrating our 5th anniversary this September and are considering a trip to Maui in late August (also our last trip before we start TTC#2). Airline prices seem to be about $650 for that time period, is that a good price from the midwest (KC)? We definitely like to stay cheap, so we'll be more interested in condo rentals than in the big hotels. That said, can anyone give me a rough estimate of what a week in Maui cost (airline, condo, food, entertainment, etc)? Thanks!

[justHB]

$650 from the midwest doesn't seem awful to me, but you might be able to find better if you go with a package deal. If you check out Pleasant Hawaiian Holidays, you can usually get a good price for airfare/hotel (or condo) trips that are cheaper than if you price them out individually.

It's hard to give a rough estimate of what a week in Maui will cost you as it's hard to tell what sort of activities you'll be doing, how often you'll be eating out, where you'll be eating out, what type of car you rent, and all that other stuff. We went in February and stayed in a pretty high end condo in the Kapalua area. Airfare, condo, and car rental was approximately $3k total, plus we spent about another $1k on food and activities. Hawaii is certainly not a cheap place to go, but it can be done for less than what we spent.

[wildcat]

justhb - thanks! I know it depends on what we do, where we stay, etc...but I was just curious how much others had paid so I'd know what to expect. We tend to stay/drive cheap and splurge on the activities/dining/entertainment, so that gives me a good idea! Thanks! I'll definitely check out that website!

[Makena]

We're going in October. I booked everything separate because that's where I found the best deals. It's always good to price it out both ways, individually or as a package deal.

Our flight from the east coast (NJ) is $425/round trip pp. $850
Condo through vrbo.com, www.ainanaluresort.com $140/night for 9 nights $1400 incl. tax
Car rental, through Costco.co is $325 + I have a coupon for free upgrade

[Ohana]

We just came back yesterday from Maui, and man, I'm missing the sunshine already!

Wildcat ITA that how much you spend will depend on what you do, where you eat, etc. We were there with our 2 small children, so we did not eat in fancy restaurants or do many activities. They liked the pool too much to do anything else! We stayed at a hotel my SIL set up through her work and ate in casual, family friendly restaurants. Even so, we spent at least $50 per meal. Groceries were also expensive. I picked up snacks, breakfast items, juice, and milk, and it was also $50. I admit, I had a bit of sticker shock (even though this was not my first trip to Maui, and I knew things would be expensive). But we had a fabulous time and it was definitely worth it!

[Makena]

I'm seriously counting down the days until we leave...and it's still 3 months away!! I'm so excited to be going back :)

I have a question....
We're staying at a condo in Lahaina, and I was hoping we could sneak over to the Westin for the day and hang out at the pool. What are the chances they won't kick us out for tresspassing?? Do you think they'll even notice that we're not guests at the hotel?

[Ohana]

Makena We stayed at the Westin when we were there a couple of weeks ago (sigh...it's already been that long?), and I don't think you will have a problem. They do ask for a name and room number if you're getting towels (and they give you a wristband to denote you're a guest there), but I saw a lot of people without wristbands, and I saw a lot of people with personal beach towels around the pools. I would just keep a low profile and snag a chair away from the little shops/towel hut/restaurants, and you should be fine.

[Makena]

Thanks Ohana!

[vee05]

Ladies need help :)

I am looking for a nice romantic place for dinner one night any recommendations?

TIA

~V

[Ohana]

vee Where are you staying? Will you have a rental car? Are there foods you and your DH love/hate? What's your budget? If you're staying at one of the resorts, some of them (like the Westin) offer a private sunset dinner with your own chef and server. If we didn't have the kids with us, I would have done that in a heartbeat earlier this month!

Otherwise, I think the other ladies will likely have good ideas. When we go to Maui, it's like going home for DH, so we go to all the hole in the wall family joints that he went to as a child instead of the newer, nicer restaurants.

[vee05]

Ohana,

Wer staying at the Sheraton. We will have a rental car. Just DH & I so budget isnt really an issue. We love trying out food. We are Indian so spicy isnt an issue either. Just good authentic food and a nice fun place.

-V

[Ohana]

Vee The Sheraton has Dinner Under the Stars (http://www.sheraton-maui.com/re_dinner.htm), but holy smokes, it starts at $200 a person!

[wildcat]

hey girls - I did a search and didn't come up with anything, so sorry if this is already posted somewhere.

My DH and I are headed to Maui in November for a week to celebrate our 5th wedding anniversary (a few months late but the first time we can get away!). We're booking flights, condo, car now. One of the nice hotels is completely out of my budget and we're looking at ocean front condo's in the Kaanapalai area. Has anyone ever stayed at the Mahana? I found an unit on vrbo.com that looks great, 10th floor, total ocean view, $145/night. Seems reasonable but wanted some opinions. Any other ideas on where to stay in that price range?

On the Road to Hana - do you recommend doing it all in one day or staying a night in the Hana area? We have heard both and wanting some more advice, especially from those that have done it.

Any other advice on see/do is great! I've read through this thread and added the Old Lahaina Luau and the magic show to my list, but haven't made my way through the general Hawaii thread yet.

What are your thoughts on doing a helicopter ride on maui? yea or nay?

TIA!

[justHB]

If my memory is correct, I think the Mahana is a little further north of the Kaanapalai area. While on the water, my recollection is that the actual beach in front of that area isn't so great.

As far as the Road to Hana is concerned, my recommendation is to do it all in one day. At this point, you can only drive to the 7 Sacred Pools anyhow and then have to turn around and go back the way you came - you can't drive all the way around the island anymore due to downed bridges from the earthquake. It's an all day trip, but totally doable.

[ladyco4]

Wildcat, my DH, DD and SIL stayed at the Mahana this past March. The rooms/condos we had were nice but needed some updating. The first room/condo that DD/SIL were given they didn't like so they asked if they could have another room/condo. The front dest gave them another room/condo to look at and if that room/condo wasn't acceptable they would be given another room/condo! They liked the second room/condo so they didn't need to check out any others. Their room/condo needed to be updated in the bathroom and living room/bedroom furniture. There was a guest book in the room that the owners had left asking for feedback both positive and negative as to what they could do to make the room/condo more comfortable.

The room that DH and I got was great for us from the start. The carpeting was a little dirty but we didn't care. We were supposed to have a studio but got a 1 bedroom/2 bath condo. We asked why and were told that the owner had downgraded the condo to a studio because it only slept 2 instead of 4 like a 1 bedroom unit is supposed to. The 1 bedrooms usually have a sleeper sofa to accomodate 2 more people. The views from both rooms(ours was on the 5th floor DD/SIL's was on the 7th) were awesome! We were there when the whales were there and every day we were able to see a lot of whales! Again, just awesome!

The lanai's on both condos were very spacious. Ours had a table and 4 chairs and a lounger. DD/SIL lanai had a table and 4 chairs. We had plenty of room for all of us to have meals out there. The kitchens came stocked with basic household items: plates, silverware, serving dishes, pots/pans, dishwasher, oven, refridgerator.

The hotel/condos are only feet away from the beach, really! The swimming right in front of the hotel isn't good for swimming/snorkeling(too rocky) but if you go only 50 feet in either direction you can have some great swimming/snorkeling. They also have a tennis court if you play tennis.

There isn't a restaurant attached to the Mahana but you do have charging priveledges(sp) at the 2 hotels nearby. There is a shopping center with in walking distance with small shops and a grocery store. We stocked up on groceries for breakfasts/lunches and then went out for dinner.

We really enjoyed our stay at the Mahana and are planning on going again soon.

Have a great trip,
Ruth

[Makena]

wildcat, check out the Aina Nalu (http://www.ainanaluresort.com/index.php). It's in Lahaina, about 2 blocks from Front St.

I booked a 2br/2bath condo for $140 a night through vrbo.com. They just renovated the entire place...it looks fabulous. And the reviews on TripAdvisor.com- Aina Nalu (http://www.tripadvisor.com/Search?where=body&returnTo=&geo=1&pid=214&SearchTeaser=%28your+destination%2C+hotel+or+attra ction%29&q=aina+nalu) can't be beat. They are putting in a new pool...scheduled to be open by the end of July.

[justHB]

I saw this article and thought it had good, pertinent information for everyone looking to go to Maui.

What's new on Maui? EVEN MORE UPSCALE LODGING, PLUS NEW FERRIES, RESTAURANTS AND ATTRACTIONS
By Carol Fowler, Special to the San Jose Mercury News
Article Launched: 09/23/2007 02:01:22 AM PDT

Building cranes tower over the palm trees on Maui these days like giant praying mantises, swinging and swaying to the luxury condo boom. It's generating a huge shift in Maui accommodations.

Vacation housing isn't the only new thing on the island. The Superferry is poised to make daily runs between Honolulu and Kahului, Maui, as soon as its legal challenge is resolved.

And the beach gets some competition as the natural draw. Agritourism has sprouted into a full-grown activity with several farms offering tours, tastings and shopping. Sunrise still attracts throngs to the 10,023-foot summit of Haleakala, but now sunset draws the crowds as well for stargazing.

And, of course, new restaurants and shops open daily. Here's a rundown on what's new on the island:

ISLAND-HOPPING

• Hawaii Superferry

The new Superferry may be the most significant change in island-hopping since the airlines began jet service in the 1960s, though at press time the ferry remained out of service because of a temporary restraining order sought by environmental groups.

The four-story catamaran Alakai, which carries 866 passengers and 200 vehicles, had started service late August between Maui and Oahu before the injunction. Court hearings are ongoing during September to determine whether the ferry can use the Maui harbor without an environmental assessment being conducted.

The crossing takes three hours - comparable to all the to-do involved with flying between the islands. Food, entertainment and shops are on board, and passengers can take in the awesome beauty of the islands from the sea. Fares are adults, $52-$62; children, $41-$51; vehicles, $59-$69 with $15 fuel surcharge.

Details: Hawaii Superferry, (877) 443-3779, www.hawaii superferry.com.

Cruises

Offering a different kind of sail, American Safari Cruises will initiate Hawaii itineraries in December. The Maui itinerary of the 39-passenger Safari Explorer will stop at Maui, Lanai and Molokai - plus drop anchor at Molokini for snorkeling and explore the coast of Kahoolawe, a rare opportunity. It will dock at Lahaina, unlike most other cruise ships that call at Kahului.

Details: American Safari Cruises, (888) 862-8881,

www.amsafari.com.

HOTEL HAPPENINGS

Don't try to book a room at the Kapalua Bay or Wailea Renaissance hotels. They have been torn down. The Ritz-Carlton Kapalua is gutted and closed until early next year. Adding to the budget traveler's dilemma, Maui County officials have cracked down on unlicensed vacation rentals, closing about 50 of them in July. The future holds fewer, but more plush rooms, and more privately owned vacation properties. What this means for the visitor with a moderate vacation budget is hard to say. But so far, Maui has had no trouble filling its resort rooms at an average rate of $241 per night in 2006. That's the highest rate in Hawaii.

• Kapalua

Kapalua Resort is undergoing Maui's most dramatic transformation. The Residences at Kapalua and the Ritz-Carlton Club, Kapalua Bay, will replace the Kapalua Bay hotel at the north end of Maui with stunning views over the ocean and to Molokai. Prices start at $3.9 million for the three- and four-bedroom residences; fractional ownership at the Ritz-Carlton Club, $300,000. These posh digs are expected to be ready in mid-2009.

Kapalua's other major hotel, the Ritz-Carlton Kapalua, is undergoing a $125 million transformation. The number of rooms will drop by about 80 to create 107 one- and two-bedroom privately owned residential suites, which will be available to hotel guests, as well as 363 renovated rooms. Aqua wallpaper and curvy French-inspired furniture will disappear in favor of rich colors, wood, stone and even bone.

"I want you to walk into this hotel and feel like you're in the skin of a Hawaiian," said the hotel's cultural adviser, Clifford Nae'ole.

The trend to "plantation" decor with lavish use of dark woods and pale walls is typical on the Islands these days. Mauve and turquoise tropical prints and rattan furniture are passe.

Kapalua's other new offerings already are available and absolutely free. The Village and Maunalei Arboretum hiking trails are newly opened, the first in a series of 100 miles of footpaths. And, should you want to spend the night at Kapalua, the Villa condominium units continue to take in guests on the ridges and along the fairways of this popular resort.

Details: Kapalua, (800) 545-0018, www.kapalua.com.

• Kaanapali

A bit south, at Kaanapali Beach, the Royal Lahaina Resort has just redone the 12-story Lahaina Kai Tower. Rooms have emerged with dark woods and pale walls, 330-thread-count Egyptian cotton sheets and 32-inch flat-screen televisions. In the future, villas and a new spa will be added. The hotel is famous for its nightly luau and tennis ranch.

Details: Royal Lahaina Resort, (800)222-5642,

www.royallahaina.net.

• Wailea

Wailea, at the south end of Maui, is having a growth spurt as well. Here the building cranes are at work a bit inland, creating several condo complexes. On the beach, the Wailea Renaissance closed its doors early this month, and will be replaced by the Wailea Baccarat, the first hotel from the company that produces French crystal for kings. The new resort will consist of 193 luxury privately owned condominiums, replacing 348 hotel rooms. Opening is slated for 2010.

The renovated Wailea Beach Marriott Resort & Spa is not a distant mirage, but a finished project. The new look is understated and elegant, with lots of dark wood, tile floors and Marriott's white "Revive" beds. The hotel's new Mandara Spa made the Condé Nast Traveler "2007 Hot Spa List." Happily, one thing will stay the same - the rocking chairs in the open-air lobby still look out toward the garden entrance.

Details: Wailea Baccarat, www.waileabaccarat.com.

Wailea Beach Marriott Resort & Spa, (800) 228-9290, marriotthawaii.com.

ON THE MENU

At the Four Seasons Maui, a new restaurant, DUO, featuring dry-aged, bone-in prime rib, Kobe beef steaks and Berkshire pork chops, replaced the hotel's Pacific Grill in March. For those who bypass red meat, the menu's "sea" section includes opakapaka, Hawaii's prime white fish, and Keahole lobster.

Mala Ocean Tavern, which opened about two years ago at the edge of Lahaina, is due to spin off another site in Wailea, though lease arrangements are not final. The Lahaina location is wildly popular with people jamming the front walk each night waiting for a table on the deck or in the narrow inside space, to chow down on bruschetta, organic chicken pita salad and Balinese stir-fry. Chef-owner Mark Ellman, one of the original 12 chefs of the Hawaii Regional Cuisine coalition, also is behind the helm at Maui Tacos and Penne Pasta Cafe.

Rooftop dining has come to Lahaina. The Lahaina Store Grille and Oyster Bar, a relatively new restaurant, has al fresco dining on the roof. True, you'll look down to Front Street through utility wires, but you'll still be catching world-class sunsets.

In other restaurant news, the Kapalua Bay Club, long loved for its stunning setting, is due to be rebuilt. The Royal Lahaina has plans to open a Don the Beachcomber restaurant, a tiki-themed drinking-dining place that should be at home in Hawaii.

Also new on the culinary-cocktail circuit are the release of Maui-produced Ocean Vodka and a new Roselani ice cream flavor, Aloha cherry truffle.

Details: DUO, 808-874-8000, www.fourseasons.com/maui.

Mala Ocean Tavern, (808) 667-9394, www.mala oceantavern.com.

Lahaina Store Grille and Oyster Bar, (808) 661-9090, www.lahainastoregrille.net.

HIKE, ZIP, ZOOM

For thrill-seeking travelers, Kaanapali Beach now sports a new zip line that takes daredevils down a 1,000-foot drop from Mount Kahalawai above the beach resort. The new line joins Skyline Eco-Adventures' other zip line on the flanks of Haleakala, which was the first in the country.

Kite boarding is the other new activity. The boarders skim over the waves standing on something barely bigger than a skateboard while hanging onto a parasail. Check out the action at Kanaha Beach Park in Kahului.

For those with more quiet activities in mind, Kaanapali Beach has laid out an historical trail marking sites of an ancient Hawaiian village and battlefield on today's manicured golf courses and resort grounds.

Details: Skyline Eco-Adventures, (808) 878-8400,

www.skylinehawaii.com.

LATE-NIGHT MAUI

Maui nightlife is pretty tame. Most bars close around 10, and there is just one nightclub, in the Hyatt Regency. But Star Gazers Maui is now offering after-dark tours to the top of Haleakala. The company sets up a computer-controlled telescope in the Crater Overlook parking lot three nights a week, serving sandwiches and hot chocolate in the 10,000-foot chill.

Details: Star Gazers Maui, (808) 281-9158, www.star gazersmaui.com.

[Katie]

Thanks for posting that justHB! We are leaving for Maui in 11 days and I couldn't be more excited!!

We are actually doing the zipline (Skyline Eco-Adventures). Anyone ever done this before with them?

This will be our 3rd trip to Maui (first time since our honeymoon 5 years ago) and I'm already planning the restaurants we want to go to!

[justHB]

we did the zipline in kauai, but not on maui. how was it? where did they take you?

[Bloomwood]

We're heading to Maui in Feb. Last time there we ate at David Paul's and Mala Ocean Tavern (other places, too, but those were the highlights).

Based on what I just skimmed Mama's seems to be over-rated. What are the other big recs? I'm guessing we'll try to go back to DP's. Bummer is this is our second HI trip where I can't eat the fish as I'm pregnant. I'll make up for it with (virgin) pinas though :p

We're staying at the Four Seasons, but I imagine we're open to going where ever for dinner.

[JFlo]

We were in Maui in May and would highly recommend Nick's Fishmarket at the Fairmont Kea Lani...wonderful service, wonderful food. And just a short walk from the Four Seasons on the beach path!

[laura]

We liked Nick's and also Spago at the Four Seasons when we were in Maui - much better than other Spago's I have been to. Sansei is good for sushi (also for steak, that's what I had). We did not care for Mama's as much as I have seen others rave about it. I mean, it was okay, but the service was not fantastic and the food was just ok for us. Not worth the drive from the FS, IMO.

[Rosebud]

If you are in Lahaina, you might try I'o (http://www.iomaui.com/) for dinner. We were really impressed with the food and service.

[Bloomwood]

If you are in Lahaina, you might try I'o (http://www.iomaui.com/) for dinner. We were really impressed with the food and service.

THAT's the other place we ate!! I couldn't remember it. It was really good and I loved sitting outside. There was a luau at the place next door so we got to cheat and catch some of that too.

[wine_o_girlie]

Bloomwood,

We went to David Paul's twice during out visit, that's how much we liked it! We really, really, really enjoyed Mama's Fish House but my DH has a friend who lives on the island and he called that day and got us "hooked up" so that may be why are service was phenomenal and we had an amazing table.

Our other favorites (much more casual) were Sansei and Aloha Mixed Plate. Our absolute best lunch was the taco truck at Makena for mahi mahi fish tacos. Heavenly. :) If you are staying at the FS you will be close to the taco truck. I would like to try Nick's if we make it back to Maui any time soon (so jealous of you West Coasters!)

Why is all fish off limits to you? I ate a decent amount of fish while I was pregnant, I just limited the high mercury fish (tuna, etc.). I don't think you should have to skip all fish.

[Yvangeline]

I also loved Mama's Fish House, but it is CRAZY expensive. However, since I wasn't paying, I didn't really care about that ;) Another good (and much more reasonably priced!) place in that area is the Paia Fish Market.

We stayed in Haiku this time around and I enjoyed myself sooooo much more than when we stayed in Wailea! Such a different vibe to the upcountry/north shore part of the island.

[Ohana]

Our other favorites (much more casual) were Sansei and Aloha Mixed Plate.


Oh yeah, Aloha Mix Plate is my favorite restaurant in all of Hawaii. Just thinking about their kalua pig sandwich is making me drool!

[FallingforPhil]

I'm a huge PITA this week, bumping all the Hawaii threads--sorry! :o After great advice from all the CC ladies, we've settled on Maui. We're looking at several properties on vrbo.com, all at very reasonable prices.

My question is this: Given the choice, would you rather stay in the South (Kihei) or more Western (Honokowai, Kahana, Maalaea)? We'll have a car, so location to other things isn't necessarily paramount. Any pros/cons of either direction? I can provide links to the specific condos, if that's helpful.

TIA!

[laura]

We stayed in Wailea, so the Kihei side of the island would be preferable to me, but really just b/c I am more familiar with it and I know there are a lot of good restaurants there. ;) Though on the map, it doesn't look like Maalaea and Kihei are very far apart at all.

[ejs]

I love the south side. Maalaea isn't that far from Kihei, but there isn't much to do there. The aquarium is there and most of the whale and dolphin watching boats leave from there.

Wailea is more resort-like and upscale. Lahaina is more like a beach town, and it's windier.

[FallingforPhil]

Thanks, Laura and ejs, that's very helpful!

[diam124]

I've stayed in Lahaina once and Wailea twice. I much prefer the Wailea area, so I would choose Kihei I think.

[justHB]

I wouldn't stay in Maalaea - the beaches aren't all that great and there's nothing to do there besides the acquarium. My favorite area is Wailea, followed by Kapalua and then Lahaina and Kehei.

[Bloomwood]

Bloomwood,
Why is all fish off limits to you? I ate a decent amount of fish while I was pregnant, I just limited the high mercury fish (tuna, etc.). I don't think you should have to skip all fish.

you know, after I posted that I wondered that myself. I think I was just ultra-paranoid as I was only 9 weeks with my first. I will be eating the fish!!

We're off to Maui this Thursday. Has anyone eaten at Capiche? DH found it on TripAdvisor and wants to check it out. I think we'll also hit David Paul's again and we'll be having dinner at the FS on Thursday.

We're doing a sunset sail, getting massages and doing the road to Hanna. We weren't able to last time as DD was a teething mess - not what I wanted to deal with in a car all day.

I just can't wait, but I'm going to miss DD something fierce!

[ktsb]

Bloomwood be sure there is no sign of MS if you're doing the Road to Hanna. It made me sick when I wasn't PG.

[Bloomwood]

haha, well I do get carsick, but the ms has passed for the most part. Thanks for the head's up!!

[FallingforPhil]

Has anyone eaten at the Maalea Waterfront (http://www.waterfrontrestaurant.net/index.htm) or the Five Palms (http://www.fivepalmsrestaurant.com/)? We're looking for a good spot for dinner on our first night that close-ish to our condo in Kihei.

[Rosebud]

Here's a good article from the L.A. Times on dining in Maui:

20 cheap eats under $20 on Maui (http://travel.latimes.com/articles/la-tr-mauia6apr06?parent=hawaii&type=destinations)

Everyone wants to score a first-rate deal on the road. But deals can be difficult to come by in a tourist zone -- especially one like Maui, where the cost of dining can be as breathtaking as the landscape.

So we went to the people who know Maui best -- its residents -- and asked them for suggestions on how to eat well here on a budget.

Our local experts included Charmaine Tavares, the mayor of Maui; Bobby Santos, chef instructor of the Maui Culinary Academy; students at the academy; Bonnie Friedman, cookbook author; and Benita Brazier, of the Maui Office of Economic Development.

Their advice helped us develop this list of 20 great Maui meals for less than $20, our second in a series of occasional stories on getting the best value for your vacation dining dollar.

(Continued at link above)

[ktsb]

The fam and I are heading to Maui in November. This time, with the addition of a toddler, we're going to go the condo route.

DH has been assigned the tast of arranging this vacation and has selected Ekahi in Wailea.

Anyone else been there, driven by there, etc?

My main criteria was to be in the Wailea area this time. We need a kitchen in the room. I don't need to be on the beach but it should be walkable. Last time we were at the Hyatt. We're trying to hold the daily loding cost to around $300 per night and I prefer accomodations to run in the 4 star area.

Any other lodging reccs??

[justHB]

If the Ekahi is the one I'm thinking of, you're technically walkable to the beach but it's on the other side of the highway a bit further up the hill. Or is that the Grand Champions?

[ktsb]

You are right it is on the beach which is a big plus.

[hokiegirl]

For those that did Road to Hana - I read that there is a CD that highlights things to look for during the drive. If you picked this up, did you find the CD useful?
We'll be in Maui for 5 days and so excited to read through this thread to figure out what to do and some recommendations on what to eat!

[Ohana]

DH is a local boy, so he and I are more into eating at local style places than at the five star restaurants, so please take my suggestion with a grain of salt. My favorite restaurant on Maui is Aloha Mix Plate. It's right next door to the Old Lahaina Luau and the Cannery Mall. Lots of great local food, eaten outside, and very reasonably priced. We try to go there every time we visit Maui.

[Oakley]

hokiegirl- We did use a CD and found in only somewhat helpful. We used our "Maui Revealed" book a lot more during the drive.

Ohana- We found that place and it was a GEM!!!! Very cheap happy hour, great food, great atmosphere, and at night we could hear the luau going on next door! We went there every day. I can't wait to go back!

[wine_o_girlie]

Aloha Mixed Plate is some good cheap eating! Other great cheap eating is the "Jaws Fish Taco" truck near Baby Beach in Makena. Yum!!!!! It's on the side of the road and it's awesome for fish tacos.

For fancier and much, much, much pricier eats, we loved Mama's Fish House in Paia and David Paul's in Lahaina.

[FallingforPhil]

hokiegirl, We opted to just use our Maui Revealed book, and we thought that was fine. We got a super early start, and were able to take our time and make lots of stops.

And, I second (third?) Aloha Mixed plate. One of the yummiest meals we had while we were there.

We didn't go as upscale as Mama's Fish House, but we did eat at the Maalaea Waterfront, which was awesome. You've got to sit outside, though, or the view is totally wasted.

[hokiegirl]

Ohana - I love local suggestions. I'm used to authentic foods since my family is from Oahu, but DH has never been to Hawaii so I'll about exposing him to local fare. Also, why spend the money on stuff you can get better and price nicely! Thanks!
oakley and Falling - thanks for the suggestion. I picked up the Kauai Reveled book and didn't think to pick up the Maui Revealed also. I'll order that now!
wine_o - yumm... I'll about some good fish tacos. jotting those places down as well. Thanks!

[ktsb]

We did the CD thing although we had a book as well. The CD we had was entertaining and the last thing I wanted to be doing was reading on that road.

Definitely taking down all of these local reccs.

We're booked for Wailea in September.

[risa00]

We decided to go to Maui at the end of August and I'm hoping we can get some help on where to say. We're looking at either 7 or 8 nights. I was thinking one of the below:

7 nights at Maui Prince
8 nights at Wailea Marriott (every 4 night free therefore 8 nights)
4 nights at Maui Prince then 3 nights at Four Seasons
4 nights somewhere in West Maui and 3 nights at four Seasons

It'll just be me and my DH since my parents are watching our DD. I appreciate any help yall can provide since I've been researching this forever and have no clue. TIA!

[linekelei]

The Four Seasons is amazing, so even if you can only do 3 nights there, I highly recommend it. We just got back from a one-week trip and I'm telling you, there is no other hotel that compares. The Marriott was the first hotel in Wailea and seems to be outdated. I don't much about the Maui Prince, but I have been to the Westin in Kaanapali, which is nice. I'd consider doing 4 nights in Kaanapali and 3 nights at the Four Seasons in Wailea. Or if you can do it, 3 nights in Kaanapali and 4 nights at the Four Seasons. It is TOTALLY worth the money.

[Jennifer]

Risa00 - I'd definitely think about 4 nights up in West Maui and then 3 at the Four Seasons - I really love West Maui - to me there is more off beach to do and IMO there are much better dining options - but the beaches in Wailea are amazing. We've been splitting our time between the two areas of Maui the last few times we went - really a perfect mix!

[risa00]

We booked it about a week ago and are doing 4 nights at the Sheraton and 3 nights at the Four Seasons. I'm very excited! And glad I booked it when I did as the price just went up $780 (for those 4 nights) for the Sheraton for some reason.

Which restaurants would you recommend?

[linekelei]

risa-I researched a ton of restaurants (we're into food) and we made reservations for every night. We ate once in Lahaina at David Paul's Lahaina Grill, which was wonderful. I highly recommend it. When you are at the Four Seasons, you should try Ferraro's at sunset-good Italian food, beautiful beachside location. We also ate at Spago, Nick's Fishmarket (at the Fairmont), Joe's, and Mama's Fish House. We did not eat at Duo (at the Four Seasons), as we'd read mediocre reviews and didn't feel like steak while in Hawaii. Of all of the restaurants, Mama's was by far our favorite-wonderful fresh fish and a beautiful location. Make sure to request a window table! Overall, we had good experiences at all of the restaurants we ate at, but make sure you go to Mama's.

[Jennifer]

Risa down in Wailea strangely enough our best quality meal was at the Tommy Bahama cafe at the shops at Wailea - beyond that we like Ferrars at the Four Seasons - just a wonderful experience being out near the water. I'm going against every other review I've read - but I have had once of my worst expensive dining experiences ever at Nick's Fishmarket - horid service (couldn't even get wine!) and not one course of mine was edible - and no one noticed or cared. Even with only the glass of wine we had being the ones in the bar waiting for our table our check was over $200 - not worth it IMO.

Up in Lahaina my favorite restauarnt is David Pauls - it's actually one of my fav restaruants anywhere - not just on Maui. I also love Kimos - just for really simple fish preperations and the tables right on the water. There is a newer place that is roof dining on Front Street (I'll come back when I remember the name) that was surprisingly good and has nice views of the harbor! I also love I'O down at 505 Front Street. For lunches or casual food I really love Aloha Plate in Lahaina and the Barefoot grill up in Ka'anapali.

[Ade]

DH and I are headed to Maui in August. It's our first time on this island, but we have been to Kauai, Oahu and The Big Island before. We most likely going to stay in Huelo at the start of the Hana Hwy, either Huelo Point Flower Farm (http://www.mauiflowerfarm.com/guest.htm) or A'apali Cliffhouse (http://www.maui.net/~paliuli/cliffhouse.html). Huelo seems like a good location to easily explore the Hana Coast (probably where we want to spend most of our time), but still have access to Lahaina or Wailea. We're really adverse to super touristy things, so wouldn't want to stay in either the entire time. Also, we live in Southern California, so would rather see waterfalls and lush jungles over sunny beaches. But, I have a few questions on what to do when we're there.

1. Lanai or Molokai for snorking? DH and I are both avid scuba divers, but I'll be 4 months pregnant, so only able to snorkle. Since we are pretty experienced, we'd like to do our own thing, versus a boat snorkle tour and Molokini just seems WAY too crowded.

2. We want to do a spa day. Is the Grand Wailea worth the $500-600 it would be for both of us, or is it a bit overhyped? Any other great spa recommendations?

3. Any restaurant recommendations in upcountry? Paia is the nearest large town.

4. Any good surfing spots on the north or East side?

We already have Maui Revealed which seems to detail the great hiking trails and sights in Hana, and that's probably how we'll spend the rest of our time. Thanks for any advice!

[justHB]

Everyone typically recommends Mama's Fish House (in Paia) and while I am glad we had the experience, I didn't love it. But that seems to be one sentiment out of hundreds who do, so take it for what it's worth.

We went snorkeling on Lanai during our February 2007 trip to Maui and it wasn't that great of an experience - you can get the same type of snorkeling at Napili and Kapalua Bay, truthfully. I've never been to Molokini but that's only because the time I tried to go the waters were too choppy so we got diverted to "Turtle Town" instead.

[laura]

I was meh on Mama's Fish House too. I think it was just overhyped for me. Nick's was only okay for us too, but we had a late reservation on our first night on the island and we were ridiculously tired- honestly most of it is a blur. My best meal on Maui was at Spago at the Four Seasons; I've been to Spago other places and it doesn't compare. I think my husband would probably say his best meal was at Sansei for sushi, or we both really enjoyed Sarento's on the Beach- although my husband was highly suspicious when we pulled up to the Best Western! The food was delicious and so was the view.

We snorkeled Molokai when we were there, and I liked it. I haven't snorkeled Lanai so I have no comparison to that.

[Ohana]

Ade I don't know about snorkeling on Molokai, but you can snorkel on Lanai. DH is from Lanai, and the snorkeling off Hulupoe Bay (http://www.gohawaii.com/lanai/plan/things_to_do_on_lanai/attractions/points_of_interest/hulopoe_bay) is pretty good.

Trilogy (http://www.sailtrilogy.com/pages/index.php) offers a tour-type deal that takes you from Lahaina to Lanai, feeds you lunch, and takes you back. The beach is not too far from the boat harbor, and I assume participants just walk over. This is pretty spendy, though (189 per person).

Alternatively, you can take the passenger ferry (http://www.go-lanai.com/)from Lahaina to Lanai and then walk over to the beach from there. The fare is $25 per person each way. The beach on Lanai has restrooms, but no other facilities. You will need to either bring your own food and beverages or walk up to the Four Seasons Manele to eat.

The pros to going with Trilogy is that everything is taken care of for you, but it's spendy and you have to go by their schedule. Taking the ferry gives you more flexibility on time because they have multiple sailings a day, and it's cheaper. However, you'll have to transport your own gear and take your own food and drinks.

One note of caution, though. The waters can be pretty rough as you get close to Lanai, and I've seen many, many people get sick on the boat just before reaching Lanai. Regardless of which option you choose, I would highly recommend making sure you carry a barf bag and wipes.

[Ade]

Thanks for all of the quick replies! I didn't realize Mama's was in Paia. Since it is so popular, I just assumed it was in either Lahaina or Wailea. Good to know! It will be our anniversary while we're there, so maybe we'll make a reservation.

If the ferry to Lanai is only $50 roundtrip, that's half the cost to Molokai. But, now I guess the question is, is it really worth it to go to either, or could we find just as good, if not better snorkling on Maui?

Anyone been to the Grand Wailea spa? My friend, who considers herself a spa afficianado, recommended it. I don't have a problem spending the money if it's really worth it. But, if there is somewhere else that is a great experience as well, then I'm open to trying it. Also, being pregnant, saunas, steamrooms and many of the treatments are out for me. So, I don't want to go pay $250 for a massage and not be able to enjoy any of the other ammenities.

[Yvangeline]

We had a great meal at Paia Fish Market. It's not fancy at all (you order at the counter and eat at indoor picnic tables), but the food was great.

Ade, I was looking at the A'apali Web site, but it's hard to tell how many bedrooms all the different houses have. I'm trying to figure out a family vacation for next April and I'm wondering if it might be a possibility. Do you know how big the different houses are? Thanks!

[wendalah]

Ade: If you are pregnant, I wouldn't bother with the Grand Wailea spa, because one of the chief attractions is its water therapy (they have different baths--mud, papaya, etc.). It would be way too tempting. It is a very nice spa, though.

As for snorkeling--we thought Lanai was amazing. We stayed at the Manele Bay and snorkeled right at that beach, and saw some pretty incredible reef formations and fish. You may like Molokai for a day trip in general, though, if you are into non-touristy travel. There are a lot of truly awe-inspiring sites on that island.

[Ade]

Yvangeline, I believe both residences are 1 bedroom and accomodate 4 people each. Unfortunately, they are having plumbing work done the week that we will be there, so we'll be staying at Huelo Point Flower Farm instead. I never did get a rate for A'apali, but it does look absolutely incredible, so we were a bit disappointed. Here are links to all of the different places we were checking out in Huelo
Maui Retreat (http://mauiretreat.com/)
Huelo Point Flower Farm (www.mauiflowerfarm.com)
Huelo Point Lookout (http://www.maui-vacationrentals.com/)
Cliff's Edge (http://www.cliffsedge.com)
A'apali Estate (http://www.maui.net/~paliuli/estate.html)
Maui Teahouse (http://www.maui.net/~teahouse/index.html)
Most have multiple places to rent on the same grounds. Also, thanks for the restaurant feedback. I think that is the same place that a friend of mine told me about and she said it was wonderful.

wendalah, thanks for the honest feedback on the Grand Wailea. That's what I thought, the baths do look amazing and I wasn't sure how much I'd be able to participate. We are also looking at Maui Spa Retreat (http://www.mauisparetreat.com) in Makawao. Anyone been there? Thanks for the feedback on Lanai. We'll probably just do one of the islands and it seems like Lanai has better ferry times, so we'll probably go there.

[laura]

I'm pretty set on celebrating my 30th bday in Hawaii; I am leaning toward 5 nights on Maui and 5 nights on the Big Island. I think we will be going with another couple. For Maui, I am trying to figure out if we should stay in Wailea at the Four Seasons (stayed before; I loooooved it but my husband thought it was overpriced/overrated/boring) or if we should stay in Lahaina at the Westin. Any thoughts?

[Ohana]

We stayed at the Westin last year, and although it was really nice, I like the Sheraton better. We stayed at the Sheraton for our wedding, and I felt it had a nicer poor and overall was a nicer property.

[Yvangeline]

Any recommendations for Maui rental condos for a family vacation? We will be two couples and three kids (two girls and a boy), so we'll probably need at least three bedrooms. We'd prefer to have easy access to a beach - or if not, a pool.

Thanks!

[justHB]

My ILs rented a 3 bedroom/2 bathroom at the Grand Champion Villas in Wailea for our wedding and it easily accommodated 6 adults. It was privately owned so the decor could have used some updating but the space was really great. It was on the golf course so not exactly on the ocean, but the stars at night up there were just amazing b/c there were no lights. It was also VERY quiet while being a 5 minute drive to the beach. The pool was a 30-second stroll.

[ktsb]

I just returned from Maui yesterday. Sigh.

We rented a condo in Ekahi in Wailea. We were in a unit very close to the large beautiful pool which sits directly adjacent to the beach. The beach was beautiful, calm and you could snorkel off it too see a family of turtles and all sorts of fish. We were in a one bedroom which slept 6 although I don't see how 6 could be that comfortable. You could rent adjacent condos however. This complex was great for us and our 2 year old DD.

Laura I can see pretty big differences between staying in Wailea vs. staying in Lahaina/Kaanapali. Lahaina is more "hopping" and you can walk from one place to another while Wailea has beautiful big beaches but not so much entertainment along the beach. At either place you can easily drive to the other.

[laura]

Wow, I'm dragging my feet on booking my Maui hotel! I am going to be there Nov 14-18. I really want to stay at the Four Seasons, but I feel guilty with the economy blah blah blah. Grand Wailea is now offering 4th night free (as opposed to FS's 5th night free) which puts it at about half the price as FS. I know they are right in the same area - has anyone stayed at the Grand Wailea recently? Any thoughts?

[laura]

Or any feedback about the Sheraton Maui Resort near Lahaina? I haven't ever stayed in that area before, only Wailea. OTOH, we are traveling with friends who are kind of crazy so they might appreciate the faster pace in Lahaina-?

[Ohana]

We stayed at the Sheraton when we got married 6 years ago...I think it's been renovated since then.

I thought it was very nice. Great pools, on a very nice (albeit crowded) part of the beach. Within walking distance to Whaler's Village for shopping and restaurants. I believe they participate in the super cheap shuttle to Lahaina. I've never stayed anywhere but the Lahaina area on Maui, so I have nothing to compare it against, but the Sheraton is definitely nicer than the Westin (where we stayed 2 years ago).

[wine_o_girlie]

We spent our last night in Maui at the Sheraton and it was fine and nice. Not to be a total brat but it was definitely more than adequate (especially for the cheap price on Hotwire) but it didn't like blow my socks off or anything like the FS. Our room was very nice (we got a free upgrade) and the grounds were pretty but the pool area was very basic IMO. I liked the Westin pool area much better but didn't walk the Westin grounds or see a room. I will say though that the Westin pool was PACKED and it was kid central (not sure if you care or not). It was nice to be able to walk to Whaler's Village and a couple of restaurants for lunch/dinner from the Sheraton.

I was totally *fine* at the Sheraton for one night but probably wouldn't want to spend a week there, especially if I had previously been exploring the FS. HTH.

[Ohana]

That's funny, I thought the Sheraton pool was much nicer than the Westin's. Same with the grounds. Having stayed at both the rooms at the Sheraton are most definitely larger and since they've recently remodeled (I think), they're likely nicer, too.

[Yvangeline]

I'll be staying here (Kahana Outrigger) for a week next April, with family. Does anyone know anything about the area? I gather that it's near Lahaina. I haven't spent much time in West Maui, so any suggestions on things to do, places to eat, etc. would be appreciated.

http://www.comeseemaui.com

[ivansbabe]

The next time DH and I go back we'll definitely be stopping at the natural foods grocery store on the road that leads to the Lahaina/Wailea split. What bugged me most was the lack of vegetables to be had. Unsubstantial salads definitely didn't do it for me. So I'd stock up on a weeks worth of healthy snacky foods. A bag of carrots, some broccoli, nuts...
We stayed at the Westin and liked it (early November). There weren't a lot of kids that time of year and it was before the Thanksgiving rush so it was ideal in that sense. We booked our trip with Costco travel and that made it very easy, and we got a deal for a free breakfast every morning at either the Westin or the Sheraton. The Sheraton was okay, but we liked the Westin better. The Hyatt seemed really nice too, their grounds were lovely and had a somewhat secluded feeling, though the beach wasn't as large. The Westin had an easier access to everything since it's in the middle of the beach area which was nice.

I'd go up to the Nakalele Blowhole about a half hour or so north of the resorts. You can "hike" (a relatively easy walk on a rocky downhill slope) down to it...it's pretty cool. There are also a couple good snorkling places around that area too. DH and I just rented the gear and drove up and down that side of maui stopping at recommended places.

[fifibee]

Laura -- Did you end up staying at Grand Wailea (http://www.grandwailea.com/)? I'm wondering what your feedback is. We're thinking of going there sometime in Feb 2009 and booking a 2 bedroom suite since we'll have family with us (and 2 young kids) so it seems like this resort is our best option in terms of everything for everyone. Would love to hear what you have to say. TIA!

Wow, I'm dragging my feet on booking my Maui hotel! I am going to be there Nov 14-18. I really want to stay at the Four Seasons, but I feel guilty with the economy blah blah blah. Grand Wailea is now offering 4th night free (as opposed to FS's 5th night free) which puts it at about half the price as FS. I know they are right in the same area - has anyone stayed at the Grand Wailea recently? Any thoughts?