PDA

View Full Version : Mother charged in death of infant


amtaylor
02-14-2006, 08:16 AM
What do you think? Too harsh... not harsh enough?


Mother charged in death of infant
Asleep, she rolled on girl, police say

Corinne McCarthy is charged with involuntary manslaughter.
Story Tools
Printer Friendly Email to a Friend
Enlarge Font Decrease Font
More Crime & Safety
Easley appoints Assistant DA Baddour to fill Barber's seat
Sheriff defends sex in busts
Wife tells of cutting up bodies
Security guard charged in theft of computers
Former inmate faces inquiry
Church fire called arson; 10th in Ala.
Sarah Ovaska, Staff Writer
Natalia McCarthy, whose mother was charged Monday in her death, lived just six weeks. Authorities said her life began with cocaine in her blood and ended when her sleeping mother rolled on top of her, smothering her.

Corinne Julianne McCarthy, 29, who lived on Old Faison Road in Knightdale, was arrested by the Wake County Sheriff's Office and charged with involuntary manslaughter and maintaining a dwelling to keep drugs. She was in the Wake County jail Monday night with bail set at $21,000.

"We're actually shocked at the charges; I never expected it," said Nancy McCarthy, Corinne McCarthy's mother. "This girl has been suffering since it's happened."

Natalia died May 4 after McCarthy, who was in the gray, cinder-block home alone, awoke and found the infant was not breathing, court documents say. A gram of marijuana, a joint, a scale and an ashtray with white powder were found in the home, court records show.

The child's birth on March 22, 2005, caught the attention of authorities when cocaine was found in her blood, according to the court papers.

Wake County Child Protective Services began an investigation when Natalia was born, but it was unclear Monday what was done to protect her. State law restricts information that can be released on child abuse and neglect cases.

Warren Ludwig, director of child welfare for Wake County, said he was not allowed to release information about the child. The agency expects to release limited information in coming days, he said.

When she died, Natalia, who was fed formula, had no drugs in her system, said Phyllis Stephens, sheriff's office spokeswoman. Stephens said the sheriff's office consulted with prosecutors from the Wake District Attorney's Office and decided to charge McCarthy because authorities thought the negligence rose to a criminal level.

McCarthy's family in Texas said they had no idea McCarthy, who had a 1994 misdemeanor conviction for breaking and entering, would be charged in her daughter's death.

Corinne McCarthy was on her own when she had Natalia, Nancy McCarthy said. Corinne had lived in the Knightdale area for the past 12 years and worked as a waitress. She was not working during her pregnancy and the weeks after Natalia, her only child, was born.

Nancy McCarthy said she did not believe Natalia was born with cocaine in her system. "They shouldn't have found a speck in that kid," she said.

She added that if Corinne McCarthy did use cocaine, "it wasn't during her pregnancy."

After the girl died, Corinne McCarthy came to Texas to be with family. Discovering that she had returned to Wake County, investigators went to arrest her, Stephens said.

Donnie Wall, 56, a neighbor on the stretch of rural road, said that he did not know McCarthy well and that she had few visitors. She was so thin he had not known she was pregnant, he said. Court papers showed her as 5-foot-9 and 145 pounds when Natalia died.

Wall said he never saw Natalia.

Detectives stayed at the house for hours on the day of the child's death, he said.

"I had a feeling they weren't going to let it go," he said Monday night. "I thought they would have her before now."

He said McCarthy would often be at home when he returned to his own house at the end of the day. She always left her porch light burning when she was in. On Monday night, the house was dark.http://www.newsobserver.com/media/2006/02/14/reg-1186270-741642.embedded.jpg

maxandmolly
02-14-2006, 08:39 AM
Under no circumstances should a baby who tested positive for drugs at birth be sent home with the mother who took them while pregnant, and here is a great big fat example of why.

oldsalt
02-14-2006, 08:42 AM
I'm not sure anything is harsh enough.

dionysia
02-14-2006, 09:33 AM
Taking the current circumstances as I understand them only (i.e., not the circumstances surrounding Natalia's health at birth), I have a couple of questions: was the mother under the influence of drugs when she rolled over onto the baby? If so, she should be charged as she is.

If not, how is this any different from a co-sleeping parent who accidentally rolls over on their baby?

Di

jp'swife
02-14-2006, 09:42 AM
I have a couple of questions: was the mother under the influence of drugs when she rolled over onto the baby? If so, she should be charged as she is.

I was wondering this too.

amtaylor
02-14-2006, 09:57 AM
That's a good question! I heard this story on the radio and tried to find out more. This is all they've released so far. It does say they found drugs in the house, but that's about all.

So... are they saying that God forbid something happens while you co-sleep that your criminally liable?

dionysia
02-14-2006, 10:09 AM
So... are they saying that God forbid something happens while you co-sleep that your criminally liable?That's what I would wonder too, if it's determined that the mother was sober when the incident occurred.

Di

jp'swife
02-14-2006, 10:20 AM
So... are they saying that God forbid something happens while you co-sleep that your criminally liable?

Oh, that is scary!!
I know that one of the main concerns in regards to co-sleeping is that it's a danger if a parent is under the influence of drugs or alcohol. I can understand that because when you are out, you're out. No waking up easily.
Under normal circumstances, I would just think (hope!) it would be a HORRIBLE accident????

lawyerlee
02-14-2006, 10:42 AM
Taking the current circumstances as I understand them only (i.e., not the circumstances surrounding Natalia's health at birth), I have a couple of questions: was the mother under the influence of drugs when she rolled over onto the baby? If so, she should be charged as she is.

If not, how is this any different from a co-sleeping parent who accidentally rolls over on their baby?

Di
This was my thought, exactly. I think whether she was under the influence at the time makes all the difference in whether the charges are appropriate or not. So I guess I would like to know more information.

What a horrible and sad outcome for this baby. :(

JamBray
02-14-2006, 11:07 AM
I agree...if she was under the influence then it puts the story into a different perspective to me.

What I don't understand is at the beginning of the article it states that the little girl was born with cocaine in her blood, but then Corinne's mother states that she wasn't. So is the mom in denial? Was the hospital wrong? I'd be curious to hear more about that also.

amtaylor
02-20-2006, 07:17 PM
Here's an update on this story...

Mother reported on cocaine as baby died
Social workers let woman keep infant

McCarthy, 29, is charged with manslaughter.

Corinne McCarthy was on cocaine when she rolled onto her infant daughter, smothering the sleeping baby, a Wake County prosecutor said Thursday.

The child, Natalia, had been born six weeks earlier with the drug in her own system.

McCarthy, 29, was arrested Monday and charged with involuntary manslaughter more than nine months after the death of the 10-pound baby with dark brown hair and brown eyes.

Before she died May 4, Natalia and McCarthy had fallen asleep on a couch in their Old Faison Road house. When McCarthy awoke, she found Natalia wedged between her body and the couch, according to the report on Natalia's autopsy. The child wasn't breathing.

Natalia, who was fed formula, had no cocaine in her system when she died, according to the Wake County Sheriff's Office.

But McCarthy did, said Amy Guy, an assistant district attorney handling the case.

Inside the home, court documents say, investigators found the butt of a marijuana joint in a trash can, white powder in an ashtray under the couch and a blue M&Ms lunchbox containing a bag with white powder residue. They also found a scale and, littering the bedroom floor, empty baggies.

The drug use, coupled with the circumstances of Natalia's birth, led to the decision to charge McCarthy, Guy said Thursday.

Myra Cogdell, a longtime friend of McCarthy's, said this week that she watched with relief as hospital workers took a urine sample from Natalia after her birth March 22.

She thought McCarthy was using cocaine during her pregnancy but had heard only denials. If there was cocaine in Natalia's system, surely the baby would then be kept safe, Cogdell recalled thinking. But after Natalia died, Cogdell was surprised when McCarthy told her that child welfare investigators had come to her house only once.

3 investigator visits

Wake County Child Protective Services workers met with McCarthy three times: at the hospital, once at a public health center and once at her home near Knightdale, spokeswoman Jane Martin said Thursday night.

Efforts to reach McCarthy, who was released from the Wake County jail Wednesday after posting $21,000 bail, were unsuccessful. At her house Wednesday night, knocks went unanswered as loud music poured from the home.

Wake County Child Protective Services plans to release details about its involvement with the mother and daughter in coming days, as state law requires.

No specific N.C. laws

North Carolina, like most states, does not have specific laws to govern situations in which children are born with cocaine or other drugs in their systems.

Twelve other states have reporting procedures written into their laws. Twelve and the District of Columbia automatically classify a drug-tainted birth as child abuse or neglect, according to the National Clearinghouse on Child Abuse and Neglect Information.

The federal Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act requires that each state have at least an administrative plan for when a newborn has been exposed to drugs or alcohol.

In North Carolina, protocol requires a case worker to visit a mother and child within 72 hours of the birth, as happened in McCarthy's case, and to ask doctors, relatives and others whether the mother can care for the infant, said JoAnn Lamm, a state health and human services official in charge of child welfare.

Case workers try to let infants remain in their families' homes, Lamm said, except when the baby is at a high risk of neglect or abuse.

Mom's spare home life

Corinne McCarthy lived alone, without a car, in her blue cinderblock house on a rural road off U.S. 64. She didn't work during her pregnancy or after Natalia's birth, family and friends said. Before her pregnancy, she worked waitressing gigs that never became steady jobs.

McCarthy always paid her rent on time, said Letty Liles, her landlady. Liles visited several times and watched McCarthy dote on her newborn. Liles said she didn't suspect drug use but told McCarthy she needed to use a bassinet after seeing Natalia asleep on the couch.

McCarthy had few close friends because the cocaine drove people away, Cogdell said. McCarthy's mother, Nancy, lives in Texas, and other relatives are scattered around the country.

Cogdell and McCarthy met as teenagers when they attended school in Wendell but took different directions, said Cogdell, a nursing student and mother of three. But the women kept in touch, and over the years Cogdell urged her friend to get help.

"She loved that baby but she wasn't strong enough to get away from that drug," Cogdell said. "It's a shame that they didn't just take that baby."

Over the holidays, when McCarthy spent two months with her mother in Austin, Texas, Nancy McCarthy worried that her daughter was suicidal. Corinne McCarthy couldn't watch commercials that showed babies and avoided looking at baby clothing when shopping at department stores, her mother said.

If Corinne McCarthy saw a child that looked like Natalia, "we'd have to leave the store." She cried daily, her mother said.

(News researcher Brooke Cain contributed to this report.)

sea74
02-22-2006, 02:13 PM
The whole story is sad.
Over the holidays, when McCarthy spent two months with her mother in Austin, Texas, Nancy McCarthy worried that her daughter was suicidal. Corinne McCarthy couldn't watch commercials that showed babies and avoided looking at baby clothing when shopping at department stores, her mother said.

Yeah, I'm sure the mom was sad over her baby's death, but she was on drugs and I think she should face the punishment now.

What did find odd is that in both articles, they point out that the baby
was FF fed. Why is that important?

Dally
02-22-2006, 02:18 PM
sea74--I think the stories point it out so you know the baby wasn't getting drugs through BM.

ETA: What a sad story. Poor baby. :(

philnikki
02-22-2006, 02:29 PM
What a failure of the state, first of all, not to protect that child! How in the world you find cocaine in a child's system and think its ok to release it to its mother is beyond me, especially given the circumstances in this case.

I am sure that the mother loved her baby, but she should have NOT been responsible for an infant if she couldn't even take care of herself.

So, so sad :(